Mysteries Department
Sign inRequest access
Run · Proto-cuneiform: the archaic texts of Uruk

Where the EN signal comes from: archive split and within-name position

Transliteration order within a case is partly editorial (Born and Kelley 2021), so the position result is provisional until collated.

0

Result

RunMeasuredResultAgainstDecisionDate
RunElement share by archive group against a resampling null; count of names with EN first against a within-name shuffle{'EN_first': {'p': '<0.0002', 'first': 54, 'names': 80, 'expected': 33.2, 'shuffle_95': [25, 42]}, 'PAP_first': {'first': 6, 'names': 27, 'shuffle_95': [7, 17]}, 'S_excavated': {'null_95': [0.056, 0.169], 'observed': 0.105}, 'S+EN_excavated': {'n': 124, 'null_95': [0.121, 0.25], 'observed': 0.161}, 'S_unprovenanced': {'null_95': [0.067, 0.123], 'observed': 0.13}, 'S+EN_unprovenanced': {'n': 416, 'null_95': [0.127, 0.2], 'observed': 0.296}}Resampled Uruk III administrative signs (archive split) · 5,000 within-name shuffles (position)Exploratory, decided after the main run. The EN enrichment is confined to the unprovenanced group (mostly Schøyen, 'Umma?') and absent from the excavated archives, so it counts against a general Sumerian naming signal. EN is strongly name-initial in the editors' order, which is evidence for an en-X template only if collation confirms the order.

What it used and found

Figures 2

Figure 1

The EN-name excess sits in the unprovenanced Schøyen and Brussels accounts, not in excavated Jemdet Nasr and Uruk

Share of names containing Englund's elements plus EN, by archive group, against 5,000 resampled pseudo-names

010203040names with an element (%)Unprovenanced (416 names)Excavated or museum (124 names)
010203040names with an element (%)Unprovenanc…Excavated o…
namesnull 2.5th percentilenull 97.5th percentile
Excavated names fall inside the null range. Most unprovenanced names come from a few Schøyen tablets attributed to Umma with a question mark.
Drawn by the site
Figure 2

EN is written first in two-thirds of the names that contain it; other common name signs are not fixed in place

Names of two or more signs: times each sign is transliterated first, against 5,000 within-name shuffles

0102030405060names with the sign firstEN (80)AN (30)BU (40)E2 (32)SZU (24)PAP (27)
0102030405060names with the sign firstEN (80)AN (30)BU (40)E2 (32)SZU (24)PAP (27)
observed firstexpectedshuffle 97.5th percentile
Order is the editors' transliteration order, which Born and Kelley show is partly conventional; collation against the tablet images is needed before this counts.
Drawn by the site

Parameters

groups = unprovenanced = Schøyen, Musées royaux Brussels, private; excavated or museum = everything else, nshuffle = 5000, nsim_groups = 5000, position_signs = ['EN', 'AN', 'BU', 'PAP', 'E2', 'SZU'], min_name_length = 2

Cite it

Mysteries Department. (2026). Where the EN signal comes from: archive split and within-name position [Run RUN0DFQT8EXEJAZ]. https://mysteriesdept.com/r/RUN0DFQT8EXEJAZ
Private beta Downloads are for beta members

We're in a private beta while we get things right. Everything here is free to read; downloading datasets, sources and code is open to members for now.

It takes a couple of minutes. We'll reply by email.