Mysteries Department
Sign inRequest access
Research session 5 · Voynich Manuscript

Re-analysis from the transliteration; book v1.0

The project was found to hold no machine-readable text: the spring findings were a language model's descriptions of images. Every claim was tested against the ZL3b, IT2a and CD2a transliterations, and none of the lexical readings exists in the manuscript. The earlier draft was archived. Structure, statistics, slot grammar, line effects, the A/B difference, labels, repetition and one-to-one decipherment were rebuilt from the data, with controls, and the book was written again from them: Reading Without a Key, v1.0.

Session 522 Oct 2026Describe18 evidence

What movedNo question changed standing

No evidence yetunchanged
Most likelyunchanged
Most likelyunchanged
Answeredunchanged
22 more questions touched, none changed standing
How was the text produced on the page?
raised this session+2 evidence, 1 for, 1 neutral
Most likely
Is it a constructed or notational language?
raised this session+2 evidence, 2 for
Open
Most likely
Is it a natural language?
raised this session+2 evidence, 1 for, 1 against
Most likely
Is it meaningless text from a procedure?
raised this session+1 evidence, 1 for
Open
No evidence yet
What are the script's units?
raised this session
No evidence yet
No evidence yet
What could anchor a reading?
raised this session
No evidence yet
Most likely
No evidence yet
Most likely
No evidence yet
What is the book about?
raised this session
No evidence yet
What is the object, and who made it?
raised this session+10 evidence, 4 for, 5 against, 1 neutral
Most likely
What kind of text is it?
raised this session+9 evidence, 5 for, 4 against
Most likely
No evidence yet
Answered
When was the parchment made?
raised this session
Answered
No evidence yet
Which plants are drawn?
raised this session
No evidence yet
Who would have made and used it?
raised this session+5 evidence, 5 for
Open

What's next4 steps set

Open
Kyle's read-through and edits
Kept on this session, not tied to a questionSet this session
Open
Higher-resolution plates for print
Kept on this session, not tied to a questionSet this session
Open
Keep Appendix D's account of the earlier draft?
Kept on this session, not tied to a questionSet this session
Open
Send chapter 4 to Davis and Layfield for comment?
Kept on this session, not tied to a questionSet this session

Next steps live on their questions, where anyone can take one up.

New questions 25

What was done

Date: 2026-10-22

  • Found that the project held no machine-readable text; the spring-2026 findings were image "readings" by a language model. Tested each against ZL3b/IT2a/CD2a: none exist in the manuscript (ASSESSMENT-2026-10.md). Earlier draft moved to archive/.
  • Obtained ZL3b (13 May 2025), IT2a, CD2a and the IVTFF 2.0 spec from voynich.nu; built a reader and analysis suite (data/analysis/); five equal-length reference corpora (Vulgate, Pliny, KJV, German and Italian Bibles).
  • Re-ran codex structure, basic statistics, entropy, Zipf, word length, glyph positions, slot grammar, line/paragraph effects, A/B keyness, per-page B-score, group similarity, controlled contrasts, labels, repetition, transcription agreement; decipherment experiments (substitution search with controls, vowel-less, three-level entropy, near-twin distance profile, label structure).
  • Literature verified directly: Layfield & Davis, Digital Medievalist 19 (19 Oct 2026, "singulion" structure) answers the page-order question; Davis 2020 and 2025 codicology; Greshko 2025 Naibbe cipher; Bowern & Lindemann 2021 (our entropies match theirs); Zandbergen's quire/paint/order arguments.
  • Design: format mockups F1/F2/F3 and figure-style variants V1/V2/V3 produced; Kyle chose F2 (10×10 coffee-table) and V1 (Atlas). Built vizkit (measured layout + lint) and all figures at final widths.
  • Fetched Yale's full image set (IIIF, 2,000 px; fold-outs full size). Wrote the book (prologue, 19 chapters, 4 appendices, bibliography) and compiled: 105 pp.
  • Open items: Kyle's read-through and edits; higher-resolution plates for print (full-size downloads for all folios); decide whether to keep Appendix D's account of the earlier draft; consider sending chapter 4 to Davis/Layfield for comment.
Answers taken up again 8
Evidence found 18
Used: methods 2
Produced: sources 2

Cite it

Mysteries Department. (2026). Session 5: Re-analysis from the transliteration; book v1.0 [Research session SES0D8B8QS022BX]. https://mysteriesdept.com/mysteries/voynich-manuscript/sessions/SES0D8B8QS022BX/session-5-re-analysis-from-the-transliteration-book-v1-0
Private beta Downloads are for beta members

We're in a private beta while we get things right. Everything here is free to read; downloading datasets, sources and code is open to members for now.

It takes a couple of minutes. We'll reply by email.