Mysteries Department
Sign inRequest access
Answer · Voynich Manuscript

Whatever the symbols are, the word sequence carries information the way a language's…

Whatever the symbols are, the word sequence carries information the way a language's does: knowing the previous words reduces the cost of the next by as much as it does in attested languages (the cross-linguistic law of Bentz et al. 2017 relating unigram entropy to entropy rate).

Ruled outAnswers 2 questionsDeductiveTested0

Where it stands

Ruled outNone pieces of evidence for, one against.

What it predicts

  • the manuscript's entropy rate lies within 2 sd of the line fitted on 103 languages at its unigram entropy; the gain from word order (compressed size of the shuffled text minus the text) lies inside the language range

Evidence none for · 1 against

Word order carries almost no information
Established · weighs heavily · F-017
AGAINST

Tested by 4 runs

RunMeasuredResultAgainstDecisionDate
RUN-028bits per word saved by word order (random word ids)0.418102 languages with word spaces: 1.34-4.10, median 2.39Outside the language range (below all)22 Oct
RUN-017residual from the H1 vs entropy-rate law (word level), sd unitsh2: 1.8; compression: 2.86103 languages, same lengthOutside 2 sd22 Oct
RUN-023residual from the H1 vs entropy-rate law (word level), sd unitsh2: 1.56; compression: 2.81103 languages, same lengthOutside 2 sd22 Oct
RUN-027residual from the H1 vs entropy-rate law (word level), sd unitsh2: 1.95; compression: 3.65103 languages, same lengthOutside 2 sd22 Oct

The questions it answers

Most likelyNo answer ahead

Cite it

Mysteries Department. (2026). Whatever the symbols are, the word sequence carries information the way a language's… [Answer ANS0D8FZXDP5R7Z]. https://mysteriesdept.com/r/ANS0D8FZXDP5R7Z
Private beta Downloads are for beta members

We're in a private beta while we get things right. Everything here is free to read; downloading datasets, sources and code is open to members for now.

It takes a couple of minutes. We'll reply by email.